The comments in the NY Times blog have been overwhelmingly
positive, as have the ones here. For that, I am most grateful. Support from friends and loved ones (and
sometimes even complete strangers!) has been one of the important tools that
have enabled me to succeed so far in my lifestyle change.
I have to admit a little chuckle, however, reading the remarks
of the people who think I must have a lot of money and free time and other
special circumstances that allowed me to lose weight. I am not wealthy by any means, and although I
work at home when I am not on the road for a singing engagement, there are
never enough hours in the day.
By the time I decided to hire a personal trainer, I had been
“relocating fat” for about 7 months and had already lost nearly 80 pounds on my
own. I did that mostly through daily walks and work on the elliptical machine at my small, inexpensive neighborhood gym. When I go on the road for singing engagements (as
I did several times over the past year), I use the hotel gym equipment for cardio, I do
fitness routines in my room (downloaded for free from places like Fitness Magazine), I do DVD workouts using my laptop, or I just
walk. For weights, I use resistance bands, which are cheap and pack easily. For the past month, I have been unable to work
out with my trainer, bike, or use gym
equipment due to a broken wrist, but I walk every day and am still losing
weight without it costing me a cent!
As for the time element, who isn't overbooked these days? We make time for the things
that are important to us. It takes time out of your day to exercise. It takes
time to plan and prepare healthy meals. It takes time to use the tools and do the work that helps you become healthier. The
thing is, once it becomes habit, it takes less time. You get better at
organizing your time and making shortcuts. I tend to exercise a lot because it’s
become really important to me, but when I started out, I was shooting for half
an hour a day, five days a week. I guarantee you that you spend more time than
that watching TV. Or playing video
games. Or surfing the Internet. Or whatever your favorite downtime activity
happens to be.
Although the Times
story is billed as one person’s
weight loss journey and pushes no agenda, at least one person thought it was “misleading”
and offered “false hope”. He and several
others tried to validate the case for refusing to attempt to lose weight, citing
various statistics about most people not keeping the weight off after five
years, and the dangers of yo-yo dieting.
It’s impossible to predict what’s
going to happen five years from now, but I can tell you this: number one, two
people in my immediate family have lost weight and kept it off after lifetimes
of yo-yo dieting; and number two, I’ve yo-yo dieted for years, so I know all
about that. I know what it feels like to be on a dieting high, and I know what
it feels like when you start the long slow slide back into the fat jeans. This
feels completely different. There is no high. The honeymoon is long since over.
This is a little bit of work, every single day, and a little bit of work every
single day is not a terrible thing. Can everyone do it? Maybe not, but I’m
pretty sure I can. Do you have to have a lot of money and time and special
circumstances to make it happen? You can work with what you’ve got. You may not
be able to find extra money, but you don’t need it; it just makes things
easier. You can make the time, and you can develop any special circumstances
you find needful.
I’ve now been working on changing my lifestyle for nearly
nine months. This is not temporary. This
is not a diet, because diets are temporary. Of course if you go back to your
old habits, you’re going to gain weight again. What’s different about the program I’ve
undertaken is that you change the way you think. You learn to defeat old, bad
thought patterns. Will I always have to be vigilant? Yes, absolutely. I’ve accepted that. Will some days be terribly
difficult, and will I fall down? Oh, my yes. But I now have the tools to help
me get up and keep going. Will I gain some weight back? Most likely. I don’t have a target weight. I plan to see where my body wants to settle.
My guess is that I will discover a comfort zone, and then I will work to stay
within that zone.
My husband and I started our lifestyle change a number of
years ago, switching to organics and real food, and educating ourselves about nutrition. I read several of Dr. Andrew Weil's books, including 8 Weeks to Optimum Health. We tossed out all the processed
stuff, all the artificial ingredients, all the junk food, and stopped eating
out in restaurants so much. We started
cooking fresh foods from scratch. Now we find ourselves eating less meat and fewer
carbs naturally, because that’s what we enjoy, not because we are restricting
ourselves. I do make decisions about having treats and when to have them, but
absolutely nothing is off limits.
It is very, very difficult to lose weight and to keep it off.
But I do think what’s missing for most
people is the mental aspect. We are defeated not by a Twinkie but by our
complicated, often illogical feelings about eating a Twinkie.
This is what I love about cognitive behavioral therapy, specifically Dr. Beck's program, and
why it is so very effective. It is very no-nonsense. It’s about the here and
now. It’s about defeating negative, illogical thought patterns. It’s about
reprogramming the way you look at food. It is practical. And it is work.
For the record, I think it’s perfectly okay for someone to
say, “I am not willing to do that work. I prefer to accept myself just as I am,
and to defend my choices to a world that often criticizes me for them.” I don’t think you’re lazy or morally lax or a
horrible person if you make that choice. I wish you didn’t have to defend
yourself against such stupid and unfounded accusations. But please don’t try to
tell me that my own work is in vain and please don’t try to discourage other
people who might want to attempt the same work. I believe very strongly in body positivity,
and for me, that manifests in making my body strong, healthy, and yes, lighter
and more toned. My choice. My
preference. My journey.