DEFENDING OPERA, DEFENDING THE FAT
Over
at the Wolf Trap Opera blog, blogger Kim recently posted about a disturbing
trend in which some opera companies are writing weigh-in clauses into their
contracts: if a singer gains a certain amount of weight before the contract
begins, he or she may be fired. This is one outcome of another disturbing trend
in opera (and in society at large), of valuing people who fit into a narrowly
defined ideal of beauty over others. This ideal, of course, excludes fat
people.
It
may seem hypocritical of me, engaged in major weight loss, to find fault with this
kind of thinking. I have chosen to lose weight for many reasons. A chance at
improving my singing career is certainly one of them, but it is hardly the
primary reason; in fact, it’s more like a fringe benefit. After all, I’ve been “singing
fat” for many years now.
I
posted a comment saying that opera should be defended against the sort of
homogenization and plasticization that Hollywood has fallen prey to. (Look at
the stars of yesteryear; while there were certainly very many “beautiful people”,
there were just as many who weren’t physically gorgeous, but were all the more
interesting because of it: Humphrey Bogart and Katherine Hepburn, just to name
two).
An
anonymous poster who very much wishes she could sing responded with a very
typical anti-fat response: the world is image-conscious, that’s just the way it
is, you’re lucky to be able to sing so quit whining and hit the gym. She
reiterated these sentiments in a second post.
There
is just so much logically wrong with this that it’s hard to know where to
begin, and I’m hesitant to address it in the Wolf Trap blog because I’m not
sure Kim wants this kind of back-and-forth which may not be on topic for her
blog. However, as a singer, a lifelong fatty, and a person who is fighting to
lose weight, I feel I have to respond to this kind of thinking.
First,
I’d like to say to Anon: you and I share the same wish! I certainly wish that
all I had to do to be able to sing was go to the gym every day! Boy, that would
be a lot easier (and cheaper!) than spending so much time training my voice,
studying languages, translating scores, researching roles, staying on top of my
agent, traveling for auditions, networking, job hunting, and oh yes --- going
to the gym seven days a week on top
of all that. Yes, that would be an excellent trade.
Secondly,
I’d like to say that as a professional, managed, working singer who has had a
career as a fat person for many years; and as someone who in fact travels the
country educating young singers about how to get into the business; I have a
pretty good handle on what the realities of that business are. I know all about
how image conscious it is. The opinion of the general director whom Anon quoted
is not news to me.
Thirdly,
while I am a firm believer in dealing with the reality that is, attempting to
change an unfair or undesireable reality is not mutually exclusive. We are not
constrained to “accept the world we live in and move on”. If that advice were
to be universally accepted, there would be no progress; certainly society would
be still mired in the Dark Ages. And while we’re on the subject, please do note
(an acknowledgement would be nice, but is unhoped for) that criticism of a
situation does not necessarily equal “whining and crying”. It’s always
interesting to me that the moment someone protests against bigotry against fat
people, however reasonable their argument, they are accused of whining.
Fifth,
while I don’t dispute that the bottom line for weight loss is fewer calories,
more exercise, successful long term weight loss is in reality a great deal more
complicated, involving many psychological and physical factors that differ
according to the individual. The attempt to reduce such a complicated process
to a simple formula indicates a lack of understanding and certainly a lack of
empathy. Discipline or the lack thereof has very little to do with successful
weight loss. The fact that I can apply discipline in one area of my life does
not mean that I can apply it equally successfully in another. If that were
truly possible, then I could do anything I set my mind to; but the reality is
that every human being has certain limitations. Anon wishes she could sing. Injury
or deformity notwithstanding, there is no physical
reason why she couldn’t learn to sing. Perhaps she merely lacks the discipline.
Sixth,
Anon made an enormous and unfounded assumption that my criticism of the opera
world’s emerging image consciousness somehow equals making excuses for being
fat. My argument is that human beings come in all shapes, sizes, and colors;
and people who are not “beautiful” fall in love and have drama in their lives
and are interesting, exciting, and accomplished just like beautiful people are.
I believe, and wish that, art would continue to reflect this. This is not
excuse-making; nor is it whining. It is a valid opinion. I have no interest in homogeneity;
and as an artist, I don’t think it has a place in the kind of art I personally
am interested in hearing, seeing, and making.
Seventh,
whether or not I am “lucky” and “blessed” to be able to sing has no bearing on
this argument. I work very hard for my career and the fact that I am by nature
inclined towards this work does not make up for any inequities that might exist
in the business.
Nor
does the fact that Anon wishes she could sing and thinks that daily trips to
the gym are an easy trade for a career have any bearing on the argument. It
might be an easy trade for her, but it might be a very difficult one for someone
else. Further, it’s fallacious, because in fact there are a very great many
more factors that go into making a successful singing career than merely being
attractive.
It
probably will do no good to address these issues point by point; fat is a
hot-button issue for many people and once they hear the dread word mentioned,
it’s very difficult to get them to think about it and discuss it outside the
box. The assumptions start to pile up and pretty soon there’s a wall no logic
can penetrate. Still, I feel compelled to try. The fact that I am successfully
losing a great deal of weight doesn’t change the years I have spent as a fat
person, dealing with the peculiar forms of bigotry directed towards the fat. I
will always see that, and I hope I will always struggle against it. I also hope
I will always defend my beloved art form against what I see as the boring,
mundane, and conventional.





